Feb 092013

I enjoy Playing by Heart for what it is, a fun, if not overly dramatic, ensemble with some good performances as well as clichéd storytelling, especially in one of the storylines. That being said, this is the poorest excuse of a Blu-ray release I’ve ever come across.



Playing by Heart (1998)


The Movie
| Special Features | Video Quality | Audio Quality | Overall


Genre(s): Romance, Comedy, Drama
Echo Bridge | R – 121 min. – $14.99 | January 27, 2013 (Best Buy)/March 26, 2013 (Wide)

Directed by:
Willard Carroll
Writer(s): Willard Carroll (written by)
Cast: Gillian Anderson, Ellen Burstyn, Sean Connery, Anthony Edwards, Angelina Jolie, Jay Mohr, Ryan Phillippe, Dennis Quaid, Gena Rowlands, Jon Stewart, Madeleine Stowe

Theatrical Release Date: December 18, 1998 (limited)

Number of Discs: 1

Audio: English (DTS-HD MA 5.1), English (Dolby Digital 2.0), Spanish (Dolby Digital 2.0)
Video: 1080p/Widescreen 2.20
Subtitles: None
Disc Size: 22.1 GB
Codec: MPEG-4 AVC
Region(s): A

THE MOVIE – 3.75/5

Ensemble movies are often a mixed bag because they’re more focused on bringing together known and/or famous actors together rather than a cohesive story created to force the characters to have any sort of connection so the audience will in the end go, “Ah!” Admittedly, as much as I have enjoyed Playing by Heart over the years, the connective tissue writer/director Willard Carroll puts forth does become a tad much, as are a cliché or two… The film’s saving grace is a solid cast, however.

There are several almost vignettes to Playing by Heart all brought together in the end, but I will leave that to anyone who hasn’t seen the movie yet. Joan (ANGELINA JOLIE) is a young, strong woman who loves the night life and clubbing and meets quiet, sensitive Keenan (RYAN PHILLIPPE) who is reluctant to become involved with Joan due to something in his past; Meredith (GILLIAN ANDERSON) is a theatre director scorned by men in the past so she tries to resist the charms and pursuit of Trent (JON STEWART); Hugh (DENNIS QUIAD) is a new acting student stuck in a lifeless marriage with his wife, Gracie (MADELEINE STOWE) who is having an affair with priest Roger (ANTHONY EDWARDS); Mildred (ELLEN BURSTYN) is a loving mother at the hospital bedside of her gay son, Mark (JAY MOHR), dying of AIDS; and last are Paul (SEAN CONNERY) and Hannah (GENA ROWLANDS) who have been married for many years and plan on renewing their vows but face their biggest challenge when he confesses to having an affair years earlier.

The characters all have one thing, or people, in common but as I said, I’ll save that for the viewer. First, I will admit where the film does falter somewhat is with the Mildred/Mark storyline. While both Burstyn and Mohr give brave performances, it’s also a tad clichéd since I assume the man dying of AIDS story was in vogue in the mid to late 90s thanks in part to Tom Hanks’ Oscar-winning performance in 1993’s Philadelphia. Of course you can also exchange AIDS with another disease, so long as you have a character dying to pull at the audiences’ heartstrings. Another story thread which doesn’t exactly ring true is that between Gracie and Roger, not because Roger is a priest but compared with the others, it came across weak in the acting arena.

The film, though, excels thanks in large part to a fun but emotional performance from a then relatively unknown Angelina Jolie. At the time, Jolie had been a several films but she still was under the radar appearing in various films such as Cyborg 2, Hackers, Foxfire and Playing God before finding stardom with 1999’s Girl, Interrupted for which she won an Academy Award as well as The Bone Collector alongside Denzel Washington. Her story with Ryan Phillippe, who probably gives one of his better performances alongside Cruel Intentions, is perhaps the most interesting of the bunch and best acted as well.

The other storylines are well acted though my second favorite would have to be Meredith and Trent mainly because when I saw this I was still into “The X-Files” so seeing Gillian Anderson outside of her Scully character was fun to see combined with seeing Stewart in a feature film versus on his “Daily Show” (prior to Playing by Heart he also appeared in The Faculty). Obviously “The Daily Show” came about years later, but from the prism of time, it’s interesting to see (just like how Greg Kinnear began as a late night show host before moving onto acting).

Playing by Heart isn’t a great film but one that I can watch again and again throughout the years, not unlike You’ve Got Mail, two films that are nowhere near perfect yet thanks to the chemistry with the characters, you have a good time. If you still haven’t seen it, give it a shot either on DVD or on cable where I tend to see it on the grid every so often.


No surprise, but there’s nary a feature on this release.

VIDEO – 1.5/5

Echo Bridge Home Entertainment, via Miramax, releases Playing by Heart on Blu-ray with what I consider the worst looking 1080p transfer I’ve come across… ever. Just like the DVD released back in 2011, this has a heavy amount of interlacing but worse yet, the picture itself is so bland and the colors look pale and lifeless. I also noticed, around the edges at least, some signs of maybe sharpening done. Another pox against it is there are many instances of dirt or scratch marks littered in many scenes.

If there is anything positive, and it’s quite minimal, it appears as if the aspect ratio is finally corrected with its original 2.20 presentation (the original DVD was non-anamorphic 1.78, the re-release DVD was 1.85 but off-center).

AUDIO – 2.5/5

Not doing the disc any favors, I was marginally excited that this release was getting a lossless 5.1 DTS-HD MA track but it was tempered once the movie started as it sounded utterly soft from beginning to end. Everything from the dialogue levels were far too quiet while the surrounds, while there, was more anemic than anything. I can’t even say this is an upgrade over the DVD re-release’s stereo track, which is saying something.

OVERALL – 2.0/5

Overall, I enjoy Playing by Heart for what it is, a fun, if not overly dramatic, ensemble with some good performances as well as clichéd storytelling, especially in one of the storylines. That being said, this is the poorest excuse of a Blu-ray release I’ve ever come across. The video has interlacing issues not to mention dirt and scratch marks while the audio is, at best, average and that’s being generous. The only way I’d recommend picking up this release is if it’s cheap (i.e. <$5) and you don’t already own either of the DVD releases.


The Movieman
Published: 02/09/2013

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>